Previous entry : Emerging things I hate

Next entry : My personal Etech05 schedule for today

March 16, 2005

Clay Shirky's Etech05 Talk

I completely doubt the guy's ability to understand anything about KM, but I have to admit that he gave the most entertaining talk of the show as of now. God, he's a rhetoric genius! The talk was entitled Ontology is Overrated: Links, Tags, and Post-hoc Metadata.

So, if we get passed Shirky's chrome, what's wrong with the content per se? In my opinion, Clay actually has an over-simplified, completely deprecated and unscientific conception of what an ontology (in the KM sense) actually is. Shirky proposes that ontologies are overrated in the sense that formalizing an all-encompassing worldview is not only a pretentious utopia, it is also culturally destructive because it actually destroys a lot of useful data (namely the diversity of ontological opinions web users have on a particular class of objects). Contextually, it also implies that (semantic) web engineers expect to eventually come up with a universal, exclusive, permanent, single meta-ontology built of binary aggregations of multiple domain expert-edited ontologies that don't overlap. That is such a last century expertise on what the semantic web is about!!!!

So my rebuttal of Shirky's proposition is simple (maybe will I eventually go into every point in details) :

  1. Federated, permanent and exclusive taxonomies are not the only type of ontologies available. Actually, I don't know any, and I don't know anyone in the semantic web world wanting to impose one.
  2. For example, partial local worldviews (personal sets of technorati tags, flickr tags, del.icio.us tags, blog pings, blog categories, blog trackbacks, etc.) actually are personal binary ontologies.
  3. Personal ontologies are useful (Shirky agrees on this).
  4. Therefore, personal worldviews are useful and desirable.
  5. Entity-relation ontologies (OWL, UML, etc.) are much more expressive than binary ontologies (actually called formal contexts). That's a scientific fact.
  6. Therefore : personal use of entity-relation ontologies is useful and desirable. Just think of databases (their schemata are entity-relation ontologies). The web won't exist without them. I put this here because Shirky somehow comes to the conclusion that people are better with just tags, bookmarks and trackbacks to manage their personal worldview.
  7. Punctual, probabilistic and contextual aggregations of multiple personal taxonomies/ontologies is useful and desirable. (Shirky agrees on this)
  8. A punctual, probabilistic and contextual aggregation of multiple personal web taxonomies/ontologies is still an ontological worldview (universal or not, depending on your source corpus). That is called disambiguation, harmonization or alignment. There are working tools for doing that, like OLA. These tools do not usually rely on binary logic, but on statistical induction.
  9. Dynamic systems that build queryable aggregations of web taxonomies/ontologies, that use snapshots of the whole web, or a partial subset, as a database, is what the semantic web is all about. And intersubjective truths (compatible with the common definition of truth) do come out of queries made on these systems.
  10. Therefore : ontologies (even the entity-relation kind) and the semantic web are not overrated, utopian, damageable, etc....

So, really, I don't know what Shirky's attack on (what he considers to be) ontologies is about. It's like saying that steam power is overrated. That creationism might not be as widely applicable as previously thought. It's pointless. And it induces FUD on the semantic web and those who use it. It's mean.

Jeez, I should be more good-looking, convincing... and popular. I deserve it. ;-)

,

Posted by Vincent-Olivier Arsenault at March 16, 2005 06:31 PM
Comments

backgammon games - backgammon-games.net

Posted by: backgammon games on April 13, 2005 01:22 AM

Can anyone point me to a trustworthy foreign pharmacy, online pharmacy, or internet pharmacy? I found this site http://www.freebeeonlinepharmacy.com and it seems to be a directory of online foreign pharmacies with comments and such. Has anyone used them. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Posted by: online pharmacies on May 3, 2005 11:34 PM

Can anyone help me find a place in Miami? I need a Miami apartment rental fast. Does anyone know where to find a sublease in Miami or apartments for rent in Miami? So far this is the best place I found: www.subleaseauction.com . Any help would be appreciated. Thanks

Posted by: Miami Apartment Rentals on May 4, 2005 12:59 AM

Can anyone help me find a place in Miami? I need a Miami apartment rental fast. Does anyone know where to find a sublease in Miami? So far this is the best place I found: www.subleaseauction.com . Any help would be appreciated. Thanks

Posted by: Miami Apartment Rentals on May 4, 2005 01:00 AM

In your free time, check the sites dedicated to rules for texas hold em rules for texas hold em http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/rules-for-texas-hold-em.html free online poker game free online poker game http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/free-online-poker-game.html caribbean stud poker caribbean stud poker http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/caribbean-stud-poker.html texas holdem online texas holdem online http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/texas-holdem-online.html texas hold em poker game texas hold em poker game http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/texas-hold-em-poker-game.html video poker video poker http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/video-poker.html stud poker stud poker http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/stud-poker.html online poker game online poker game http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/online-poker-game.html poker hand poker hand http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/poker-hand.html free video strip poker free video strip poker http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/free-video-strip-poker.html poker star poker star http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/poker-star.html go play poker go play poker http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/go-play-poker.html poker games poker games http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/poker-games.html poker terms poker terms http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/poker-terms.html texas holdem software texas holdem software http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/texas-holdem-software.html rules for poker games rules for poker games http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/rules-for-poker-games.html video poker software video poker software http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/video-poker-software.html how to play poker how to play poker http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/how-to-play-poker.html holdem holdem http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/holdem.html free texas hold em poker free texas hold em poker http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/free-texas-hold-em-poker.html winning poker hands winning poker hands http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/winning-poker-hands.html how to play texas hold em how to play texas hold em http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/how-to-play-texas-hold-em.html texas holdem tips texas holdem tips http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/texas-holdem-tips.html hold em hold em http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/hold-em.html free online texas holdem free online texas holdem http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/free-online-texas-holdem.html casino poker casino poker http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/casino-poker.html poker sites poker sites http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/poker-sites.html free texas hold em poker games free texas hold em poker games http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/free-texas-hold-em-poker-games.html video poker games video poker games http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/video-poker-games.html free online poker free online poker http://www.sheratonnorthcharleston.com/free-online-poker.html - Tons of interesdting stuff!!!

Posted by: world poker tour on May 23, 2005 01:08 PM

You can probe my blogs http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/1.html www fda http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/2.html and free http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/3.html free salehttp://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/4.html buy cheap http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/5.html buy buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/6.html and sale http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/7.html www buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/8.html free buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/9.html sale and http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/10.html fda online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/11.html free online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/12.html online free http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/14.html www www http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/15.html free and http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/16.html online free http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/17.html and online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/18.html online online .

Posted by: online on May 25, 2005 04:18 PM

You can probe my blogs http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/1.html cheap buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/2.html online buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/3.html free onlinehttp://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/4.html www online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/5.html cheap cheap http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/6.html online cheap http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/7.html pharmacy online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/8.html fda buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/9.html sale cheap http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/10.html sale pharmacy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/11.html cheap and http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/12.html www fda http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/14.html buy free http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/15.html and pharmacy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/16.html buy online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/17.html buy online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/18.html www and .

Posted by: free on May 25, 2005 04:30 PM

You can probe my blogs http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/1.html buy buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/2.html buy buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/3.html www cheaphttp://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/4.html online buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/5.html and online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/6.html fda fda http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/7.html and buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/8.html online pharmacy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/9.html www buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/10.html pharmacy fda http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/11.html buy pharmacy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/12.html pharmacy sale http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/14.html free buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/15.html buy sale http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/16.html free buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/17.html fda pharmacy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/18.html and free .

Posted by: fda on May 25, 2005 04:44 PM

You can probe my blogs http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/1.html free online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/2.html fda pharmacy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/3.html buy buyhttp://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/4.html pharmacy and http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/5.html www buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/6.html free sale http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/7.html cheap online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/8.html buy buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/9.html sale buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/10.html and pharmacy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/11.html online buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/12.html buy pharmacy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/14.html cheap buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/15.html sale online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/16.html and buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/17.html online fda http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/18.html online buy .

Posted by: pharmacy on May 25, 2005 05:03 PM

You can probe my blogs http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/1.html buy cheap http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/2.html buy online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/3.html free buyhttp://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/4.html pharmacy online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/5.html buy sale http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/6.html online fda http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/7.html buy buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/8.html free free http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/9.html free online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/10.html online buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/11.html free cheap http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/12.html online buy http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/14.html sale sale http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/15.html pharmacy fda http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/16.html online online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/17.html online online http://www.speedsurf.to/mudak/18.html fda buy .

Posted by: www on May 25, 2005 05:17 PM

Please check the pages dedicated to online poker online poker http://www.williamchibbard.com/online-poker.html texas hold em texas hold em http://www.texas-hold-em-world.com/texas-hold-em.html online poker online poker http://www.texas-hold-em-world.com/online-poker.html texas hold em texas hold em http://www.e-online-poker-777.com/texas-hold-em.html online poker online poker http://www.e-online-poker-777.com/online-poker.html ... Thanks!!!

Posted by: online poker on May 25, 2005 10:45 PM

Please check out the sites dedicated to loans loans http://www.racepointfunding.com/loans.html home loans home loans http://www.racepointfunding.com/home-loans.html payday loans payday loans http://www.racepointfunding.com/payday-loans.html home equity loan home equity loan http://www.racepointfunding.com/home-equity-loan.html payday loan payday loan http://www.racepointfunding.com/payday-loan.html refinance refinance http://www.racepointfunding.com/refinance.html personal loans personal loans http://www.racepointfunding.com/personal-loans.html debt consolidation loan debt consolidation loan http://www.racepointfunding.com/debt-consolidation-loan.html payday advance payday advance http://www.racepointfunding.com/payday-advance.html credit card offers credit card offers http://www.racepointfunding.com/credit-card-offers.html ... Thanks!!!

Posted by: loans on May 31, 2005 02:53 AM

Welcome to the Pharmamx.com Family!
We invite you to visit us at www.pharmamx.com and find our great medicine prices with up to 90% discount per each item. We provide serious and first class service to all our customers 24/7. If we do not carry a medicine you need just let us know and we will be more than glad to assist you! To serve you is our goal, thank you in advance for your preference.

Posted by: Francisco Toteli on June 3, 2005 03:23 PM

Please check out the sites about online casino site online casino site http://www.djsdesigns.net/online-casino.html online casinos site online casinos site http://www.djsdesigns.net/online-casinos.html slot machines site slot machines site http://www.djsdesigns.net/slot-machines.html casino on net site casino on net site http://www.djsdesigns.net/casino-on-net.html casino games site casino games site http://www.djsdesigns.net/casino-games.html casino gambling site casino gambling site http://www.djsdesigns.net/casino-gambling.html internet casino site internet casino site http://www.djsdesigns.net/internet-casino.html online casino gambling site online casino gambling site http://www.djsdesigns.net/online-casino-gambling.html casino online site casino online site http://www.djsdesigns.net/casino-online.html roulette site roulette site http://www.djsdesigns.net/roulette.html ... Thanks!!!

Posted by: online casino site on June 4, 2005 06:07 PM

Need a bigger penis? Enlarge your penis now using penis enlargement items. Safe penis enlargement. The best penis enlargement site. More penis enlargement information available if you want penis enlargement using penis pills or other methods to enlarge the penis.

Posted by: penis enlargement on June 8, 2005 03:36 AM

Need a bigger penis? Enlarge your penis now using penis enlargement items. Safe penis enlargement using only natural penis enlargement pills to enlarge your penis. The best penis enlargement site to enlarge your penis. More penis enlargement information available if you want penis enlargement using penis pills or other methods to enlarge the penis.

Posted by: penis enlargement on June 8, 2005 02:17 PM

http://dol28.net/index1817.html http://dol28.net/index2067.html http://dol28.net/index.html http://dol28.net/index2068.html http://dol28.net/index2069.html http://dol28.net/index2076.html http://dol28.net/index2062.html http://dol28.net/index2080.html http://dol28.net/index2063.html http://dol28.net/index2064.html http://dol28.net/index2078.html http://dol28.net/index2077.html http://dol28.net/index2065.html http://dol28.net/index2072.html http://dol28.net/index2066.html http://dol28.net/index1277.html http://dol28.net/index2075.html http://dol28.net/index2074.html http://dol28.net/index2073.html http://dol28.net/index2070.html http://dol28.net/index2071.html http://dol28.net/index497.html http://dol28.net/index1207.html http://dol28.net/index1963.html http://dol28.net/index1171.html http://dol28.net/index1037.html http://dol28.net/index1035.html http://dol28.net/index1314.html http://dol28.net/index1313.html http://dol28.net/index1327.html http://dol28.net/index1442.html http://dol28.net/index1926.html http://dol28.net/index1827.html http://dol28.net/index1713.html http://dol28.net/index1826.html http://dol28.net/index1825.html http://dol28.net/index1824.html http://dol28.net/index1925.html http://dol28.net/index1924.html http://dol28.net/index1922.html http://dol28.net/index1923.html http://dol28.net/index1927.html http://dol28.net/index1921.html http://dol28.net/index1823.html http://dol28.net/index1822.html http://dol28.net/index1918.html http://dol28.net/index1920.html http://dol28.net/index1919.html http://dol28.net/index1917.html http://dol28.net/index703.html http://dol28.net/index1821.html http://dol28.net/index1820.html http://dol28.net/index1819.html http://dol28.net/index1818.html http://dol28.net/index1816.html http://dol28.net/index1815.html http://dol28.net/index1916.html http://dol28.net/index1814.html http://dol28.net/index1813.html http://dol28.net/index1915.html http://dol28.net/index1914.html http://dol28.net/index1812.html http://dol28.net/index1136.html http://dol28.net/index2003.html http://dol28.net/index1912.html http://dol28.net/index1913.html http://dol28.net/index1717.html http://dol28.net/index1911.html http://dol28.net/index1811.html http://dol28.net/index746.html http://dol28.net/index1910.html http://dol28.net/index1810.html http://dol28.net/index1909.html http://dol28.net/index1266.html http://dol28.net/index1296.html http://dol28.net/index1271.html http://dol28.net/index1267.html http://dol28.net/index1272.html http://dol28.net/index1276.html http://dol28.net/index1291.html http://dol28.net/index1908.html http://dol28.net/index1305.html http://dol28.net/index1299.html http://dol28.net/index1300.html http://dol28.net/index1809.html http://dol28.net/index1808.html http://dol28.net/index1052.html http://dol28.net/index1718.html http://dol28.net/index1716.html http://dol28.net/index1715.html http://dol28.net/index1907.html http://dol28.net/index1807.html http://dol28.net/index1806.html http://dol28.net/index1735.html http://dol28.net/index1906.html http://dol28.net/index705.html http://dol28.net/index1905.html http://dol28.net/index1904.html http://dol28.net/index2002.html http://dol28.net/index1805.html http://dol28.net/index1804.html http://dol28.net/index1803.html http://dol28.net/index1903.html http://dol28.net/index1902.html http://dol28.net/index1900.html http://dol28.net/index1901.html http://dol28.net/index1014.html http://dol28.net/index1898.html http://dol28.net/index1899.html http://dol28.net/index1802.html http://dol28.net/index1897.html http://dol28.net/index1719.html http://dol28.net/index1021.html http://dol28.net/index1801.html http://dol28.net/index1799.html http://dol28.net/index1711.html http://dol28.net/index1732.html http://dol28.net/index1896.html http://dol28.net/index1895.html http://dol28.net/index1894.html http://dol28.net/index1893.html http://dol28.net/index1892.html http://dol28.net/index1797.html http://dol28.net/index1798.html http://dol28.net/index1796.html http://dol28.net/index1730.html http://dol28.net/index1114.html http://dol28.net/index1795.html http://dol28.net/index1891.html http://dol28.net/index1890.html http://dol28.net/index1889.html http://dol28.net/index1720.html http://dol28.net/index1294.html http://dol28.net/index765.html http://dol28.net/index1190.html http://dol28.net/index1794.html http://dol28.net/index2001.html http://dol28.net/index1888.html http://dol28.net/index1887.html http://dol28.net/index1793.html http://dol28.net/index1792.html http://dol28.net/index1886.html http://dol28.net/index1279.html http://dol28.net/index1791.html http://dol28.net/index1790.html http://dol28.net/index1323.html http://dol28.net/index1789.html http://dol28.net/index1885.html http://dol28.net/index204.html http://dol28.net/index571.html http://dol28.net/index761.html http://dol28.net/index552.html http://dol28.net/index578.html http://dol28.net/index757.html http://dol28.net/index570.html http://dol28.net/index550.html http://dol28.net/index421.html http://dol28.net/index1312.html http://dol28.net/index774.html http://dol28.net/index759.html http://dol28.net/index617.html http://dol28.net/index760.html http://dol28.net/index566.html http://dol28.net/index576.html http://dol28.net/index471.html http://dol28.net/index30.html http://dol28.net/index562.html http://dol28.net/index546.html http://dol28.net/index568.html http://dol28.net/index616.html http://dol28.net/index544.html http://dol28.net/index574.html http://dol28.net/index554.html http://dol28.net/index573.html http://dol28.net/index535.html http://dol28.net/index719.html http://dol28.net/index716.html http://dol28.net/index715.html http://dol28.net/index513.html http://dol28.net/index584.html http://dol28.net/index371.html http://dol28.net/index222.html http://dol28.net/index600.html http://dol28.net/index556.html http://dol28.net/index558.html http://dol28.net/index548.html http://dol28.net/index586.html http://dol28.net/index588.html http://dol28.net/index560.html http://dol28.net/index233.html http://dol28.net/index564.html http://dol28.net/index580.html http://dol28.net/index598.html http://dol28.net/index596.html http://dol28.net/index590.html http://dol28.net/index106.html http://dol28.net/index594.html http://dol28.net/index758.html http://dol28.net/index592.html http://dol28.net/index100.html http://dol28.net/index604.html http://dol28.net/index478.html http://dol28.net/index727.html http://dol28.net/index1599.html http://dol28.net/index1884.html http://dol28.net/index778.html http://dol28.net/index1788.html http://dol28.net/index1322.html http://dol28.net/index1155.html http://dol28.net/index1051.html http://dol28.net/index1787.html http://dol28.net/index1883.html http://dol28.net/index1786.html http://dol28.net/index1289.html http://dol28.net/index1785.html http://dol28.net/index1111.html http://dol28.net/index1304.html http://dol28.net/index1882.html http://dol28.net/index1053.html http://dol28.net/index1880.html http://dol28.net/index1881.html http://dol28.net/index1132.html http://dol28.net/index1784.html http://dol28.net/index1878.html http://dol28.net/index747.html http://dol28.net/index1169.html http://dol28.net/index1275.html http://dol28.net/index1876.html http://dol28.net/index1723.html http://dol28.net/index1874.html http://dol28.net/index1701.html http://dol28.net/index1135.html http://dol28.net/index1783.html http://dol28.net/index1782.html http://dol28.net/index1873.html http://dol28.net/index1740.html http://dol28.net/index1872.html http://dol28.net/index1739.html http://dol28.net/index1871.html http://dol28.net/index1870.html http://dol28.net/index1731.html http://dol28.net/index1781.html http://dol28.net/index1779.html http://dol28.net/index1725.html http://dol28.net/index1777.html http://dol28.net/index1778.html http://dol28.net/index1776.html http://dol28.net/index1775.html http://dol28.net/index1868.html http://dol28.net/index1866.html http://dol28.net/index1865.html http://dol28.net/index1733.html http://dol28.net/index1864.html http://dol28.net/index1863.html http://dol28.net/index1774.html http://dol28.net/index1773.html http://dol28.net/index1772.html http://dol28.net/index1712.html http://dol28.net/index1726.html http://dol28.net/index1862.html http://dol28.net/index1771.html http://dol28.net/index1708.html http://dol28.net/index1861.html http://dol28.net/index1770.html http://dol28.net/index1710.html http://dol28.net/index1859.html http://dol28.net/index1858.html http://dol28.net/index1857.html http://dol28.net/index1856.html http://dol28.net/index1769.html http://dol28.net/index2079.html http://dol28.net/index1855.html http://dol28.net/index1854.html http://dol28.net/index1767.html http://dol28.net/index1768.html http://dol28.net/index1853.html http://dol28.net/index1852.html http://dol28.net/index1766.html http://dol28.net/index1742.html http://dol28.net/index1741.html http://dol28.net/index1163.html http://dol28.net/index1182.html http://dol28.net/index1851.html http://dol28.net/index1765.html http://dol28.net/index1281.html http://dol28.net/index1764.html http://dol28.net/index1762.html http://dol28.net/index1763.html http://dol28.net/index1761.html http://dol28.net/index1760.html http://dol28.net/index1709.html http://dol28.net/index1326.html http://dol28.net/index729.html http://dol28.net/index846.html http://dol28.net/index1333.html http://dol28.net/index1334.html http://dol28.net/index1078.html http://dol28.net/index532.html http://dol28.net/index1248.html http://dol28.net/index1055.html http://dol28.net/index1158.html http://dol28.net/index1153.html http://dol28.net/index1759.html http://dol28.net/index1850.html http://dol28.net/index1849.html http://dol28.net/index1758.html http://dol28.net/index1107.html http://dol28.net/index772.html http://dol28.net/index1309.html http://dol28.net/index1738.html http://dol28.net/index1736.html http://dol28.net/index1757.html http://dol28.net/index1734.html http://dol28.net/index1756.html http://dol28.net/index1755.html http://dol28.net/index1847.html http://dol28.net/index1754.html http://dol28.net/index1844.html http://dol28.net/index1843.html http://dol28.net/index1846.html http://dol28.net/index1845.html http://dol28.net/index1841.html http://dol28.net/index1842.html http://dol28.net/index1729.html http://dol28.net/index1728.html http://dol28.net/index1840.html http://dol28.net/index1838.html http://dol28.net/index1839.html http://dol28.net/index1837.html http://dol28.net/index1753.html http://dol28.net/index1752.html http://dol28.net/index1331.html http://dol28.net/index1836.html http://dol28.net/index1751.html http://dol28.net/index1750.html http://dol28.net/index1749.html http://dol28.net/index1835.html http://dol28.net/index1834.html http://dol28.net/index1727.html http://dol28.net/index1748.html http://dol28.net/index1833.html http://dol28.net/index1705.html http://dol28.net/index1702.html http://dol28.net/index1325.html http://dol28.net/index1005.html http://dol28.net/index1747.html http://dol28.net/index1746.html http://dol28.net/index1832.html http://dol28.net/index1745.html http://dol28.net/index1744.html http://dol28.net/index1743.html http://dol28.net/index1831.html http://dol28.net/index976.html http://dol28.net/index974.html http://dol28.net/index1040.html http://dol28.net/index985.html http://dol28.net/index986.html http://dol28.net/index1000.html http://dol28.net/index1054.html http://dol28.net/index845.html http://dol28.net/index827.html http://dol28.net/index1101.html http://dol28.net/index1032.html http://dol28.net/index912.html http://dol28.net/index990.html http://dol28.net/index995.html http://dol28.net/index1001.html http://dol28.net/index881.html http://dol28.net/index979.html http://dol28.net/index1018.html http://dol28.net/index1189.html http://dol28.net/index1829.html http://dol28.net/index1830.html http://dol28.net/index1828.html http://dol28.net/index1004.html http://dol28.net/index69.html http://dol28.net/index1133.html http://dol28.net/index1572.html http://dol28.net/index1058.html http://dol28.net/index489.html http://dol28.net/index634.html http://dol28.net/index637.html http://dol28.net/index1971.html http://dol28.net/index1970.html http://dol28.net/index724.html http://dol28.net/index1495.html http://dol28.net/index1283.html http://dol28.net/index632.html http://dol28.net/index1159.html http://dol28.net/index1608.html http://dol28.net/index1999.html http://dol28.net/index860.html http://dol28.net/index1609.html http://dol28.net/index1998.html http://dol28.net/index1445.html http://dol28.net/index1529.html http://dol28.net/index789.html http://dol28.net/index1617.html http://dol28.net/index605.html http://dol28.net/index1525.html http://dol28.net/index839.html http://dol28.net/index2049.html http://dol28.net/index227.html http://dol28.net/index868.html http://dol28.net/index1528.html http://dol28.net/index1341.html http://dol28.net/index1144.html http://dol28.net/index1090.html http://dol28.net/index373.html http://dol28.net/index583.html http://dol28.net/index581.html http://dol28.net/index769.html http://dol28.net/index819.html http://dol28.net/index817.html http://dol28.net/index53.html http://dol28.net/index1391.html http://dol28.net/index1393.html http://dol28.net/index1392.html http://dol28.net/index1390.html http://dol28.net/index1389.html http://dol28.net/index1549.html http://dol28.net/index1477.html http://dol28.net/index91.html http://dol28.net/index60.html http://dol28.net/index843.html http://dol28.net/index1478.html http://dol28.net/index883.html http://dol28.net/index1476.html http://dol28.net/index631.html http://dol28.net/index572.html http://dol28.net/index2090.html http://dol28.net/index288.html http://dol28.net/index1499.html http://dol28.net/index1707.html http://dol28.net/index795.html http://dol28.net/index1979.html http://dol28.net/index1498.html http://dol28.net/index1986.html http://dol28.net/index1567.html http://dol28.net/index1959.html http://dol28.net/index1122.html http://dol28.net/index1526.html http://dol28.net/index482.html http://dol28.net/index155.html http://dol28.net/index1002.html http://dol28.net/index1460.html http://dol28.net/index1459.html http://dol28.net/index2046.html http://dol28.net/index2045.html http://dol28.net/index2044.html http://dol28.net/index2043.html http://dol28.net/index2042.html http://dol28.net/index187.html http://dol28.net/index376.html http://dol28.net/index101.html http://dol28.net/index1201.html http://dol28.net/index942.html http://dol28.net/index1956.html http://dol28.net/index2019.html http://dol28.net/index1079.html http://dol28.net/index203.html http://dol28.net/index1012.html http://dol28.net/index1397.html http://dol28.net/index1398.html http://dol28.net/index1264.html http://dol28.net/index1950.html http://dol28.net/index2039.html http://dol28.net/index835.html http://dol28.net/index1633.html http://dol28.net/index1594.html http://dol28.net/index2022.html http://dol28.net/index1616.html http://dol28.net/index143.html http://dol28.net/index728.html http://dol28.net/index1649.html http://dol28.net/index639.html http://dol28.net/index861.html http://dol28.net/index281.html http://dol28.net/index2021.html http://dol28.net/index2020.html http://dol28.net/index1261.html http://dol28.net/index1222.html http://dol28.net/index1185.html http://dol28.net/index175.html http://dol28.net/index424.html http://dol28.net/index1485.html http://dol28.net/index417.html http://dol28.net/index82.html http://dol28.net/index1310.html http://dol28.net/index1241.html http://dol28.net/index1622.html http://dol28.net/index1542.html http://dol28.net/index105.html http://dol28.net/index1108.html http://dol28.net/index997.html http://dol28.net/index1257.html http://dol28.net/index504.html http://dol28.net/index899.html http://dol28.net/index309.html http://dol28.net/index957.html http://dol28.net/index960.html http://dol28.net/index958.html http://dol28.net/index955.html http://dol28.net/index102.html http://dol28.net/index1282.html http://dol28.net/index1672.html http://dol28.net/index2060.html http://dol28.net/index1178.html http://dol28.net/index706.html http://dol28.net/index1433.html http://dol28.net/index613.html http://dol28.net/index1451.html http://dol28.net/index992.html http://dol28.net/index1565.html http://dol28.net/index889.html http://dol28.net/index1990.html http://dol28.net/index1381.html http://dol28.net/index1467.html http://dol28.net/index1987.html http://dol28.net/index896.html http://dol28.net/index555.html http://dol28.net/index828.html http://dol28.net/index824.html http://dol28.net/index1410.html http://dol28.net/index1695.html http://dol28.net/index1694.html http://dol28.net/index1246.html http://dol28.net/index1324.html http://dol28.net/index1601.html http://dol28.net/index1985.html http://dol28.net/index1224.html http://dol28.net/index740.html http://dol28.net/index1501.html http://dol28.net/index1502.html http://dol28.net/index1142.html http://dol28.net/index528.html http://dol28.net/index1611.html http://dol28.net/index530.html http://dol28.net/index1152.html http://dol28.net/index1612.html http://dol28.net/index1140.html http://dol28.net/index1458.html http://dol28.net/index569.html http://dol28.net/index579.html http://dol28.net/index1366.html http://dol28.net/index198.html http://dol28.net/index372.html http://dol28.net/index988.html http://dol28.net/index311.html http://dol28.net/index932.html http://dol28.net/index870.html http://dol28.net/index231.html http://dol28.net/index1383.html http://dol28.net/index1409.html http://dol28.net/index901.html http://dol28.net/index182.html http://dol28.net/index176.html http://dol28.net/index829.html http://dol28.net/index928.html http://dol28.net/index1161.html http://dol28.net/index1247.html http://dol28.net/index1683.html http://dol28.net/index710.html http://dol28.net/index1993.html http://dol28.net/index565.html http://dol28.net/index1704.html http://dol28.net/index267.html http://dol28.net/index1429.html http://dol28.net/index1061.html http://dol28.net/index1031.html http://dol28.net/index1484.html http://dol28.net/index1465.html http://dol28.net/index1015.html http://dol28.net/index1347.html http://dol28.net/index1954.html http://dol28.net/index1377.html http://dol28.net/index559.html http://dol28.net/index1364.html http://dol28.net/index725.html http://dol28.net/index356.html http://dol28.net/index1150.html http://dol28.net/index52.html http://dol28.net/index750.html http://dol28.net/index1252.html http://dol28.net/index1598.html http://dol28.net/index234.html http://dol28.net/index797.html http://dol28.net/index1238.html http://dol28.net/index103.html http://dol28.net/index655.html http://dol28.net/index1654.html http://dol28.net/index553.html http://dol28.net/index230.html http://dol28.net/index2092.html http://dol28.net/index54.html http://dol28.net/index1452.html http://dol28.net/index1631.html http://dol28.net/index1033.html http://dol28.net/index1441.html http://dol28.net/index1439.html http://dol28.net/index1443.html http://dol28.net/index1931.html http://dol28.net/index1320.html http://dol28.net/index1953.html http://dol28.net/index529.html http://dol28.net/index1948.html http://dol28.net/index1930.html http://dol28.net/index192.html http://dol28.net/index519.html http://dol28.net/index1318.html http://dol28.net/index830.html http://dol28.net/index1447.html http://dol28.net/index81.html http://dol28.net/index247.html http://dol28.net/index248.html http://dol28.net/index43.html http://dol28.net/index1339.html http://dol28.net/index1962.html http://dol28.net/index1420.html http://dol28.net/index1952.html http://dol28.net/index615.html http://dol28.net/index1580.html http://dol28.net/index1581.html http://dol28.net/index2059.html http://dol28.net/index1293.html http://dol28.net/index798.html http://dol28.net/index1473.html http://dol28.net/index1160.html http://dol28.net/index1168.html http://dol28.net/index1721.html http://dol28.net/index50.html http://dol28.net/index785.html http://dol28.net/index971.html http://dol28.net/index1504.html http://dol28.net/index1505.html http://dol28.net/index1270.html http://dol28.net/index109.html http://dol28.net/index114.html http://dol28.net/index2052.html http://dol28.net/index503.html http://dol28.net/index1941.html http://dol28.net/index511.html http://dol28.net/index1490.html http://dol28.net/index1552.html http://dol28.net/index336.html http://dol28.net/index1592.html http://dol28.net/index545.html http://dol28.net/index1539.html http://dol28.net/index1980.html http://dol28.net/index1126.html http://dol28.net/index1673.html http://dol28.net/index1629.html http://dol28.net/index2035.html http://dol28.net/index2033.html http://dol28.net/index1643.html http://dol28.net/index2034.html http://dol28.net/index1344.html http://dol28.net/index1607.html http://dol28.net/index726.html http://dol28.net/index1319.html http://dol28.net/index741.html http://dol28.net/index475.html http://dol28.net/index2030.html http://dol28.net/index149.html http://dol28.net/index1010.html http://dol28.net/index682.html http://dol28.net/index1315.html http://dol28.net/index394.html http://dol28.net/index1462.html http://dol28.net/index1215.html http://dol28.net/index1376.html http://dol28.net/index1361.html http://dol28.net/index1362.html http://dol28.net/index711.html http://dol28.net/index1387.html http://dol28.net/index589.html http://dol28.net/index926.html http://dol28.net/index1468.html http://dol28.net/index1110.html http://dol28.net/index864.html http://dol28.net/index505.html http://dol28.net/index1088.html http://dol28.net/index627.html http://dol28.net/index1016.html http://dol28.net/index1198.html http://dol28.net/index1211.html http://dol28.net/index1164.html http://dol28.net/index1395.html http://dol28.net/index1292.html http://dol28.net/index1474.html http://dol28.net/index1273.html http://dol28.net/index27.html http://dol28.net/index28.html http://dol28.net/index781.html http://dol28.net/index1020.html http://dol28.net/index477.html http://dol28.net/index470.html http://dol28.net/index1121.html http://dol28.net/index495.html http://dol28.net/index496.html http://dol28.net/index701.html http://dol28.net/index702.html http://dol28.net/index1423.html http://dol28.net/index1623.html http://dol28.net/index293.html http://dol28.net/index2012.html http://dol28.net/index1677.html http://dol28.net/index625.html http://dol28.net/index1438.html http://dol28.net/index278.html http://dol28.net/index279.html http://dol28.net/index240.html http://dol28.net/index991.html http://dol28.net/index321.html http://dol28.net/index345.html http://dol28.net/index1274.html http://dol28.net/index707.html http://dol28.net/index1066.html http://dol28.net/index690.html http://dol28.net/index1077.html http://dol28.net/index1076.html http://dol28.net/index185.html http://dol28.net/index410.html http://dol28.net/index1172.html http://dol28.net/index1378.html http://dol28.net/index1614.html http://dol28.net/index1686.html http://dol28.net/index743.html http://dol28.net/index738.html http://dol28.net/index936.html http://dol28.net/index1613.html http://dol28.net/index137.html http://dol28.net/index1186.html http://dol28.net/index1187.html http://dol28.net/index607.html http://dol28.net/index1242.html http://dol28.net/index1173.html http://dol28.net/index1627.html http://dol28.net/index1625.html http://dol28.net/index1624.html http://dol28.net/index1626.html http://dol28.net/index1295.html http://dol28.net/index686.html http://dol28.net/index1183.html http://dol28.net/index776.html http://dol28.net/index1640.html http://dol28.net/index268.html http://dol28.net/index622.html http://dol28.net/index621.html http://dol28.net/index818.html http://dol28.net/index241.html http://dol28.net/index1628.html http://dol28.net/index1558.html http://dol28.net/index173.html http://dol28.net/index249.html http://dol28.net/index65.html http://dol28.net/index833.html http://dol28.net/index134.html http://dol28.net/index1223.html http://dol28.net/index483.html http://dol28.net/index316.html http://dol28.net/index1510.html http://dol28.net/index1227.html http://dol28.net/index897.html http://dol28.net/index77.html http://dol28.net/index463.html http://dol28.net/index1514.html http://dol28.net/index80.html http://dol28.net/index117.html http://dol28.net/index946.html http://dol28.net/index200.html http://dol28.net/index184.html http://dol28.net/index237.html http://dol28.net/index693.html http://dol28.net/index292.html http://dol28.net/index202.html http://dol28.net/index434.html http://dol28.net/index18.html http://dol28.net/index16.html http://dol28.net/index17.html http://dol28.net/index780.html http://dol28.net/index679.html http://dol28.net/index709.html http://dol28.net/index692.html http://dol28.net/index493.html http://dol28.net/index494.html http://dol28.net/index1508.html http://dol28.net/index1997.html http://dol28.net/index763.html http://dol28.net/index649.html http://dol28.net/index20.html http://dol28.net/index19.html http://dol28.net/index115.html http://dol28.net/index914.html http://dol28.net/index524.html http://dol28.net/index820.html http://dol28.net/index1231.html http://dol28.net/index1512.html http://dol28.net/index85.html http://dol28.net/index633.html http://dol28.net/index195.html http://dol28.net/index289.html http://dol28.net/index46.html http://dol28.net/index807.html http://dol28.net/index856.html http://dol28.net/index186.html http://dol28.net/index975.html http://dol28.net/index855.html http://dol28.net/index1099.html http://dol28.net/index90.html http://dol28.net/index744.html http://dol28.net/index1511.html http://dol28.net/index1509.html http://dol28.net/index188.html http://dol28.net/index242.html http://dol28.net/index183.html http://dol28.net/index1513.html http://dol28.net/index696.html http://dol28.net/index295.html http://dol28.net/index438.html http://dol28.net/index1973.html http://dol28.net/index1141.html http://dol28.net/index1422.html http://dol28.net/index138.html http://dol28.net/index348.html http://dol28.net/index189.html http://dol28.net/index904.html http://dol28.net/index902.html http://dol28.net/index415.html http://dol28.net/index120.html http://dol28.net/index136.html http://dol28.net/index144.html http://dol28.net/index1243.html http://dol28.net/index87.html http://dol28.net/index374.html http://dol28.net/index464.html http://dol28.net/index766.html http://dol28.net/index122.html http://dol28.net/index400.html http://dol28.net/index465.html http://dol28.net/index167.html http://dol28.net/index1425.html http://dol28.net/index119.html http://dol28.net/index506.html http://dol28.net/index44.html http://dol28.net/index307.html http://dol28.net/index8.html http://dol28.net/index5.html http://dol28.net/index6.html http://dol28.net/index7.html http://dol28.net/index9.html http://dol28.net/index4.html http://dol28.net/index3.html http://dol28.net/index158.html http://dol28.net/index1981.html http://dol28.net/index308.html http://dol28.net/index190.html http://dol28.net/index502.html http://dol28.net/index972.html http://dol28.net/index508.html http://dol28.net/index669.html http://dol28.net/index290.html http://dol28.net/index1228.html http://dol28.net/index165.html http://dol28.net/index1263.html http://dol28.net/index1212.html http://dol28.net/index1048.html http://dol28.net/index844.html http://dol28.net/index931.html http://dol28.net/index205.html http://dol28.net/index842.html http://dol28.net/index1240.html http://dol28.net/index722.html http://dol28.net/index721.html http://dol28.net/index206.html http://dol28.net/index124.html http://dol28.net/index76.html http://dol28.net/index840.html http://dol28.net/index1972.html http://dol28.net/index1269.html http://dol28.net/index351.html http://dol28.net/index168.html http://dol28.net/index661.html http://dol28.net/index359.html http://dol28.net/index1660.html http://dol28.net/index461.html http://dol28.net/index132.html http://dol28.net/index235.html http://dol28.net/index61.html http://dol28.net/index40.html http://dol28.net/index39.html http://dol28.net/index62.html http://dol28.net/index63.html http://dol28.net/index314.html http://dol28.net/index1131.html http://dol28.net/index1516.html http://dol28.net/index1664.html http://dol28.net/index1665.html http://dol28.net/index1206.html http://dol28.net/index398.html http://dol28.net/index72.html http://dol28.net/index466.html http://dol28.net/index1229.html http://dol28.net/index360.html http://dol28.net/index653.html http://dol28.net/index323.html http://dol28.net/index516.html http://dol28.net/index910.html http://dol28.net/index45.html http://dol28.net/index354.html http://dol28.net/index342.html http://dol28.net/index1091.html http://dol28.net/index2015.html http://dol28.net/index1537.html http://dol28.net/index160.html http://dol28.net/index164.html http://dol28.net/index1556.html http://dol28.net/index419.html http://dol28.net/index1559.html http://dol28.net/index362.html http://dol28.net/index74.html http://dol28.net/index665.html http://dol28.net/index809.html http://dol28.net/index650.html http://dol28.net/index1214.html http://dol28.net/index459.html http://dol28.net/index48.html http://dol28.net/index64.html http://dol28.net/index858.html http://dol28.net/index363.html http://dol28.net/index162.html http://dol28.net/index340.html http://dol28.net/index1577.html http://dol28.net/index1469.html http://dol28.net/index886.html http://dol28.net/index1109.html http://dol28.net/index1957.html http://dol28.net/index1958.html http://dol28.net/index641.html http://dol28.net/index139.html http://dol28.net/index1965.html http://dol28.net/index2040.html http://dol28.net/index2041.html http://dol28.net/index1678.html http://dol28.net/index1118.html http://dol28.net/index1680.html http://dol28.net/index107.html http://dol28.net/index825.html http://dol28.net/index135.html http://dol28.net/index1685.html http://dol28.net/index401.html http://dol28.net/index1492.html http://dol28.net/index399.html http://dol28.net/index1568.html http://dol28.net/index779.html http://dol28.net/index1100.html http://dol28.net/index944.html http://dol28.net/index1961.html http://dol28.net/index326.html http://dol28.net/index1123.html http://dol28.net/index1491.html http://dol28.net/index452.html http://dol28.net/index838.html http://dol28.net/index490.html http://dol28.net/index491.html http://dol28.net/index59.html http://dol28.net/index1213.html http://dol28.net/index358.html http://dol28.net/index509.html http://dol28.net/index1226.html http://dol28.net/index1450.html http://dol28.net/index252.html http://dol28.net/index925.html http://dol28.net/index923.html http://dol28.net/index929.html http://dol28.net/index927.html http://dol28.net/index1175.html http://dol28.net/index208.html http://dol28.net/index347.html http://dol28.net/index266.html http://dol28.net/index407.html http://dol28.net/index253.html http://dol28.net/index1069.html http://dol28.net/index689.html http://dol28.net/index1116.html http://dol28.net/index1047.html http://dol28.net/index142.html http://dol28.net/index1593.html http://dol28.net/index1527.html http://dol28.net/index800.html http://dol28.net/index987.html http://dol28.net/index1984.html http://dol28.net/index1946.html http://dol28.net/index803.html http://dol28.net/index207.html http://dol28.net/index384.html http://dol28.net/index1119.html http://dol28.net/index1285.html http://dol28.net/index1255.html http://dol28.net/index1181.html http://dol28.net/index171.html http://dol28.net/index1017.html http://dol28.net/index484.html http://dol28.net/index108.html http://dol28.net/index2087.html http://dol28.net/index801.html http://dol28.net/index677.html http://dol28.net/index1966.html http://dol28.net/index1983.html http://dol28.net/index123.html http://dol28.net/index1982.html http://dol28.net/index1647.html http://dol28.net/index1330.html http://dol28.net/index1419.html http://dol28.net/index1418.html http://dol28.net/index888.html http://dol28.net/index1939.html http://dol28.net/index1472.html http://dol28.net/index1162.html http://dol28.net/index259.html http://dol28.net/index254.html http://dol28.net/index255.html http://dol28.net/index335.html http://dol28.net/index256.html http://dol28.net/index260.html http://dol28.net/index257.html http://dol28.net/index790.html http://dol28.net/index258.html http://dol28.net/index261.html http://dol28.net/index678.html http://dol28.net/index1416.html http://dol28.net/index317.html http://dol28.net/index674.html http://dol28.net/index697.html http://dol28.net/index1046.html http://dol28.net/index327.html http://dol28.net/index1143.html http://dol28.net/index391.html http://dol28.net/index658.html http://dol28.net/index645.html

Posted by: dol28 on June 10, 2005 02:14 PM

Need a bigger penis? Enlarge your penis now using penis enlargement items. Safe penis enlargement using only natural penis enlargement pills to enlarge your penis. The best penis enlargement site to enlarge your penis. More penis enlargement information available if you want penis enlargement using penis pills or other methods to enlarge the penis.

Posted by: penis enlargement on June 13, 2005 01:18 PM